The Maranatha Academy girls basketball program has been consistently competitive over the years. The Crusaders compete in the Indian Trails Conference (ITC) as well as the Wisconsin Association of Christian Schools (WACS) postseason tournament. Maranatha won its most recent WACS Class A state championship in 2009-10, and a 2nd place finish in 2014-15. Phil Alsup began coaching the Lady Crusaders in 2018, leading the team to 3rd place in WACS for the 2018-2019 season, 2nd place in the 2020 Sabercat Invitational, and 3rd place in WACS for the 2020-2021 season. In the 2023-2024 season, the Lady Crusaders took 1st place in the Indian Trails Conference and 2nd place in the WACS Conference. Mattie Bumpus took over as head coach in the 2024-2025 season and now Emma Alsup steps into the role as first year head coach.
2025-26 Record
| Overall | Pct. | ITC | Pct. | WACS | Pct. |
| 0-0 | 0.000 | 0-0 | 0.000 | 0-0 | 0.000 |
2025-26 Schedule
| | | | | |
| Date | Time | Opponent | Location | Travel | Result |
| 11/14 (Fr) | 5:00 PM | at AOE | | | |
| 11/18 (Tu) | 6:00 PM | vs. Wisconsin School for the Deaf | HOME | | |
| 11/20 (Th - Tentative) | 6:00 PM | vs. Reuther | HOME
| | |
| WACS Tip-Off Tournament | JustAGame Fieldhouse | Wisconsin Dells | |
| 12/12 (F - Tentative) | 5:00 PM | at Mountain Top Christian School | | | |
| 12/18 (Tu) | 5:30 PM | vs. Oak Hills | HOME | | |
| 1/8 (Th) | 5:00 PM | at WI School of the Deaf | | | |
| 1/13 (Tu) | 5:30 PM | vs. Grace Christian School | HOME | | |
| 1/16 (Fr) | 5:30 PM | vs. Rock County | HOME | | |
| 1/27 (Mo - Tentative) | TBD | at Ruether | | | |
| 2/9 (Mo) | 6:00PM | vs. AOE | HOME | | |
| 2/12 (Th) | 4:30 PM | at Grace Christian Academy | | | |
| 2/13 (Fr) | 5:30 PM | at Oakhill Christian Academy | | | |
| 2/16 (Mo) | 6:00 PM | vs. Mountain Top Christian | HOME | | |
| 2/17 (Tu) | TBD | at Rock County Christian School | | | |
| 2/24 (Tu) | TBD | ITC Semi-finals | TBD | | |
| 2/26 (Th) | TBD | ITC Championship Game | TBD | | |
| 2/27 (Fr) | TBD | WACS Playoffs | TBD | | |
| 3/6-7 | TBD | WACS State Tournament | TBD | | |
*ITC Conference Games
2025-26 Roster
| No. | Name | Pos. | Ht. | Yr. |
| 2 | Macy Alsup | G | 5-5 | So |
| 3 | Lara Brown | G | 5-2 | Jr |
| 4 | Neveah LaPorte | G | 5-2 | So |
| 5 | Kathy Salazar | G | 5-2 | Jr |
| 11 | Jane Brock | F | 5-8 | Jr |
| 21 | Paige Butler | F | 5-1 | Sr |
Head Coach: Emma Alsup
Assistant Coach: Ann Bolton
Team Manager:
